Also, the scene where the killer is half crawling around with the mask on is something from a nightmare. The film smartly turns its lack of resources to its advantage via a found footage approach, making cheap, static-filled, low-quality visuals the product of its killer's camera and letting its largely unknown cast increase their plausibility as real people starring in a "documentary.". As a result, the film was banned until now, nearly a decade later. OSRS Barbarian Fishing The Easiest Way to Level Up EP. Was the film really b. Good. The lack of money went hand-in-hand with a lack of time; John Erick Dowdle shot the film in only 15 days, spending only two more on post-production. If she had just been good, he wouldnt have had to hurt her. Press J to jump to the feed. Though it may not be the scariest movie ever made, it is certainly one of the most unsettling. She suffers everything from PTSD to Stockholm syndrome as she talks about the love that her captor proclaimed for her. That explains why Foley was suspected despite not looking like the killer we see in the movie. However, the case doesnt get enough media or public attention because of the 9/11 Attacks. I didnt know anything more about the film, but it felt like a challenge, a way to prove how tough I was. Her brother, writer-director Stephen Chbosky, serves as the film's producer. The film is predominantly comprised of the over 800 tapes that have been found in his home. He kidnapped these women, tortured them in his makeshift trailer which he called the Toy Box, and then murdered them. What is Megan Is Missing about? Trending. In fact, a shorter shooting schedule may have been helpful to the actors saddled with disturbing roles; they didn't have time to get bored with their feigned terror. Ian Bradley would ride around on his motorbike following Hindley in her van. Why Do Cross Country Runners Have Skinny Legs? During the raid, they found over 800 videotapes that showed a record of the killers murders in all their horrifying details. He himself, however, claimed to have killed over 30 people, and these even included members of his family, such as his first wife and his infant daughter. She insists that her captor truly loved her. The faux-documentary approach means the audience hears a lot of graphic descriptions but don't actually see the most gruesome elements play out on-screen. The cases of this killer couple have quite a few similarities with the tapes. Sign up to receive the latest and greatest articles from our site automatically each week (give or take)right to your inbox. The film contains numerous scenes of extreme violence, including animal feces being stuck in mouths, intestines being pulled out, genitals being removed or electrocuted, people being burned alive, teeth being removed by pliers, and women being raped post-mortem. I knew it was an intensely disturbing Found Footage film and Id heard friends speak about it in the same hushed tones reserved for A Serbian Film and Salo. With no one around to punish me, I do it myself. The rawest and most lingering horror, though, might be the psychological destruction of Cheryl Dempsey. The aura of mystery about the film has been only intensified by the problems that the brothers experienced while trying to release the movie. Bout to watch the movie now cause I gotta see whats behind those gray spoiler lines. Jerry Brudos was one of Salems worst serial killers, and also one of the most bizarre. Thus, the movie is not based on a real story, but takes inspiration from several real cases of serial killers. His necrophiliac activities continued until the late stages of decomposition, or until the corpse was destroyed by wild animals. The dread slowly mounts as this trapped character realizes the situation she's in. Her brother,. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. Eventually she says what he wants her to say to make the torture stop. We never learn the identity of the Butcher or even see his face. He had attached a mirror to the ceiling to make the victims see what he did to them. I dont want to say that this film is about Hooker's case but there is something common and it makes this movie more realistic. The film begins when the authorities find more than 800 tapes in the house of a man they believe to be the serial killer infamously known as the Water Street Butcher. The mockumentary features interviews from characters who are supposed to be FBI agents, officers belonging to other law enforcement branches, and members of the families of the victims, and Cheryl Dempsey (Stacy Chbosky), the sole victim he lets go. As a mark of what's considered "low-budget" in the entertainment industry, the article looks at films made for $500k $3 million. "Poughkeepsie" was following in some big found footage footsteps, but director John Erick Dowdle prefers to downplay the movie's connection to one of its most famous forerunners. Ray had equipped his trailer using the most horrible devices of perverted torture, which he called his friends. The sloppiness Ed displays in his first killing is quickly remedied by the time he finds his next pair of victims a couple who give him a ride in their car. Definitely not for the faint-hearted, the movie has helped Dowdle establish himself as a prominent director in that genre. It creeps me out more. Since the release of The Poughkeepsie Tapes, Dowdle himself has released two more found-footage films, Quarantine, an American remake of REC, and As Above, So Below. The killer most likely followed Foley's route and killed the girls after Foley himself garnered their services in order to frame him. Beloved wife of Joseph J. Dempsey; loving mother of Rebecca Foley and husband Christopher of Sudbury, Benjamin Dem For so long, pain was my natural state and though it hurts, leaning into that fear and shame at least feels familiar. Rader also had strange sexual fetishes, just like the killer in the tapes. The tapes and the documentary were probably never seen by the police. You can also find more information, resources, and support at their website. However, in the same article, the publication mentions a report published by the Circle, in which Dowdle apparently revealed that he had no knowledge of Francois before making the film. Cheryl Dempsey was born on October 13, 1962 in Neptune City, Monmouth County, New Jersey United States. "It's a cosmopolitan area, but it has real nature and spaces where somebody could lurk and stalk people and do terrible things and probably stay unnoticed for a long time.". "I throw a bunch of paint at the wall, and he comes in and helps me sculpt it," he explained, saying their process hasn't changed. Shidehs story takes place in post-revolutionary Iran during the War of Cities and sees her not only try to cope with current events but also piece her life back together now that the revolution is over. Its my favourite horror movie but I haven't think about it this way before. This was made into a movie, and was nearly released in 2007. This vague identification allows us to project our own tormentors onto his image: the killers, the abusers, the bullies, the patriarchy itself. The killer had kidnapped her after killing her boyfriend, and had subjected her to such horrifying torture that she had become deranged, and enjoyed harming herself. I'm late, but I think the 24 tapes that were missing were taken to be used for the documentary. Serial killers in the United States If youve ever wondered how many serial killers are currently active in the United States, the answer is far from comforting. I am in danger because in allowing myself to feel good, I have forgotten to be perfect. He is convicted of murdering 49 women, mostly prostitutes, beginning in 1982, until as recently as 2001. Cheryl Dempseys story is a tragedy and a reminder of the terrible and cruel things that some people are capable of. Some of her research was academic she read tragic accounts of women who had gone through similar ordeals but a lot of it came down to raw experience. I had waited for years to see this movie since 2007 and finally 5 years ago I got to see it- its one of my favorites. Cheryl passed away circa 2007, at age 60 at death place. The psychologist says, Pain had been such a huge part of her life for so long, she didnt know how to exist without it. This sentence unlocked something in my brain that Id been struggling with for most of my life and, though triggering, helped me understand my own desire for pain and shame. The Poughkeepsie Tapes is a horror film based on the true crime of a serial killer who committed over 800 rapes and murders. Cheryl had 7 siblings: John Robert Dempsey and 6 other siblings. The tapes document years of misery and depravity inflicted at the hands of the Water Street Butcher, a Poughkeepsie-based serial killer whose crimes were even more widespread, varied, and horrific than the authorities or public could have imagined. I told myself that I wanted to be happy, but that happiness felt too risky, a sign that I had become comfortable. Maybe we can attempt to take off the masks we wear as protection and show our true faces to the world. The 2007 film has had a troubled past with release dates, so its not surprising that its not available on the streamer. The combination of these horrific acts makes it necessary for the film to be rated R in order to prevent children and some adults from viewing it. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Similarly, the nature of the crimes committed, including violent sexual, physical torture, and necrophilia, do face an uncanny similarity to the cases of several serial killers. really gave me the chills. Sometimes darkness can be illuminating, and sometimes even the most grim horror can be healing. In a powerful editorial at Ghouls Magazine, Jenn Adams explains how Cheryl's story, though extreme, resonates with her own experience of abuse and even helped illuminate some aspects of her trauma for her, providing an invaluable sense of catharsis and connection that motivated her to publish her own story. Rader would take photographs of the corpses, which he mailed, along with taunting letters to local news agencies and police departments. Kemper was notorious for performing perverted acts with the decapitated heads of his murdered victims. After being rescued, she kills herself and her body disappears from its grave. (2017), [Film Review] Sorry About the Demon (2022), [Film Review] The Killer is One of Thirteen (1973), [TV Review] Junji Ito Maniac: Japanese Tales of the Macabre (2023). Finally, the cops track the killer down, and on storming his house, are shocked to find one of his victims, Cheryl Dempsey, who was abducted as a teen 8 years earlier, still alive. This will." During the Cheryl Dempsey interview the audience witnesses a broken woman. When the killer captures Cheryl, she's a cheerful, ordinary 19-year-old girl. The credits of the film reveal that his full name is Edward Carver (Ben Messmer). Needless to say, the tapes shown in the movie have been shot by the movie-makers with a focus on giving it an authentic feel. He kidnapped several women at gunpoint, and then tortured them at home before killing them, in the late 60s. For years, if you wanted to watch "The Poughkeepsie Tapes," you were out of luck. It follows the story of the police investigation into the case, as they uncover hundreds of videotapes that the killer had made in order to document his horrific crimes. Although this might not sound like the best advertisement for the city of Poughkeepsie, Dowdle is quick to point out that the locals were thrilled to simply have their home in the spotlight. The Butcher liked to make home movies of himself stalking, kidnapping, terrorizing, and murdering his victims and the scratchy, staticky video footage his reign of terror left behind will work its way into your nightmares. They kept her as a sex slave for a period of 7 years, from 77 to 84. She started to want the role and when she got it, she put a lot of work into making her performance as realistic, heartbreaking, and painful as possible. Her message is one of hope reminding people that no matter how dark or difficult their circumstances may seem, there is always a way out and there is always help available if you know where to look for it. Once home, he would rape or sodomize the victims, before strangulating or hacking them to death. But the makers decided to pull the plug on the release at the last moment. After his execution, the cops receive a mail from the killer, telling them that they have missed a body, and it is soon clear that they had the wrong man. It seems that Cheryl was right. The big distinction between them is Francois never kept a detailed video record of his crime. Throughout the investigation, Ed remains an enigmatic figure to law enforcement. No, The Poughkeepsie Tapes is not based on a true story. According to director John Erick Dowdle's interview with BlueCat, the film's lack of distribution was more accidental than anything else; when MGM, the initial distributor, had to bail out, the movie simply fell through the cracks. When she does have thoughts of her own, they are in praise of master. As protection from his cruelty, she made herself believe that his torture was an expression of love and shes desperate to get it back. I've been meaning to watch this for years, so after seeing your post I went ahead and checked it out. One of the most unpleasant echoes is how the Water Street Butcher starts his killing with a young girl playing in her yard; many true crime scholars, as detailed on Crime Traveller, suspect that Ted Bundy's murders may have begun with him killing his 8-year-old neighbor when he was only 14. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. It's a credit to Dowdle that the lack of time doesn't show at all. The Poughkeepsie Tapes are found as well as Cheryl Dempsey, who has been kept alive for eight years. really gave me the chills. Ted Bundy was one of Americas most prolific serial killers, who murdered more than 50 young women after kidnapping them in the 1970s, though his acquaintances assert that he may have killed up to 100. His first victim is an eight-year-old girl, whom he kidnaps from right in front of her home, and then proceeds to rape and murder her. The sleepy Rust Belt town of Braddock, Pennsylvania comes alive at night with the arrival of a new resident, Martin Matthias (John Amplas), who might just be a vampire. Cheryl Dempsey was finally interviewed as well, but now she is disturbed and whispers. A series of events later, police find a victim named Cheryl Dempsey, who was kidnapped when she was a teen. With the directors admission, theres absolutely no doubt that the Poughkeepsie Tapes are a fictional creation, though inspired from real cases of serial killers. No, the Water Street Butcher is not a real person. The killer, known as Ed or Edward Carver, digs open her grave and takes her remains. . Finally, in July 2014, it was released as a video on demand edition on DirecTV briefly, before being withdrawn again. A fictional Bundy even appears in the film, advising detectives on how to catch their elusive prey. Cheryl's fate is tragic and haunting and viewer commentary shows why it's the most disturbing and emotionally affecting part of the film. Viewers still take to the internet to find out whether the serial killer in "The Poughkeepsie Tapes" is real. In the words of Cheryl Dempsey: . This makes the movie a mockumentary. That final interview scene when Cheryl absentmindedly itches her head will make even the . Indeed, misconceptions about the Water Street Butcher's reality have been so persistent that Decider's article debunking the rumors came out years after the film's wide release. But there are plenty of real life horrors on tape that people buy/watch --> scenes of death has Bud Dwyer's suicide. The Water Street Butcher is a convincing serial killer because he's a composite, cobbled together from the strategies and methods of many killers who were all too real. One of the most particularly graphic moments is the infamous barrel scene and in parts where horrific pictures come up on the screen. After all, Cheryl has most likely seen his face and might have recognized him during a possible future investigation. When the final interview takes place, Cheryl knows that the interviewer is her master. Don't you think that there are a lot of common features with Cameron Hooker case? By removing all his traces from his erstwhile home, including his fingerprints, he ensures his anonymity. During her interview, she demonstrates signs of Stockholm syndrome. Very interesting! I worry about spreading ideation and negatively affecting those who are vulnerable to the same kind of temptation. My mom taped 'Family Ties' over it, otherwise I'm sure it'd be a cult classic today! The killer had kidnapped her after killing her boyfriend, and had subjected her to such horrifying torture that she had become deranged, and enjoyed harming herself. The only way I could really ask for this was with the help of alcohol and I would routinely drink so much that I would black out, making it easier to ask for what I had decided was a shameful desire to be humiliated. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. Stacy Chbosky's interview in John Norman's "Welcome to Our Nightmares" highlights that the Chboskys are long-time horror collaborators in their own right. Written, directed, and edited by John Erick Dowdle (Full Moon Rising), The Poughkeepsie Tapes tells the story of a serial killer who prowls the streets of the eponymous city in the US state of New York. . Helen Lyle is a triple threat. And for Gemma, thats most definitely the case when she suddenly finds herself the sole carer of her young niece Cady in M3GAN (2022), Film genres are reliant on certain signs, symbols and narrative motifs to define them. I do agree that showing a snuff film, "as a movie" would get it banned from theaters. Rumors about its burial flew fast and thick. The Poughkeepsie Tapes is an American mockumentary-type horror film that was banned due to its graphic horror scene and similarities to snuff films. Despite this, Stacy Chbosky, who plays Cheryl Dempsey, is an incredibly talented actress and her performance . When Im feeling particularly fragile, I drag a thumbtack across the back of my forearm in what I think of as scratching. I rarely break the skin, but the longer the mark lasts, the more satisfying it is. This is a similar type of bargaining that he did with Cheryl, implying that he has found his new slave and long-term victim. Born on , , Cheryl Dempsey hails from , United Kingdom. The Poughkeepsie Tapes are not on Netflix. At the time of his death in 2014, he had been serving his sentence at Sullivan Correctional Facility in Fallsburg, New York. No, the Water Street Butcher was never found. [Editorial] Re-assessing The Exorcist: Religion, Abuse, and The Rise of the Feminist Mother. After eight years of some of the most brutal tortures imaginable in addition to brainwashing, she's become so broken and can barely answer any questions, and breaks down mid-interview. One gruesome similarity shared with the movie is that, Ted enjoyed putting the severed head of one victim on the body of another. If you can't hire big name actors, then your stars will feel more ordinary, real, and vulnerable. This is a really interesting theory thag makes me want to revisit it. Ed then begins stalking Cheryl, who is 19-years-old. The most interesting inspiration for the Poughkeepsie Tapes seems to have been drawn from this case. While the Water Street Butcher does kill her, the actual death scene feels like an afterthought compared to the sheer suspenseful terror of a scene that doesn't have the killer touch her at all. How much of Megan is missing is real footage? However, the character is not based on any real-life person or events, and is entirely fictional. The documentary also offers interviews with police officers, family members of victims, and even a victim herself to provie further insight into the criminals motivations and methods. She begins to believe that not only is Cheryl gone, but that he had to destroy her chosen identity because it wasnt good enough to deserve his love. Home Entertainment Movies Cheryl Dempsey: A Tale of Psychological Torment. Possessor is a slick futuristic thriller in which Tasya Vos, an assassin for hire, must manage her responsibilities as an elite killing machine and complex feelings towards her husband and son, whilst taking on another high-profile job that will push her to the edge of her sanity. Every beautiful stretch of woodlands becomes the perfect spot to hide a dismembered body. I haven't seen this movie in a while, but it fucked with me. After the credits end, one final tape of a woman being killed for good measure. Not long after Cheryl is buried, her remains are mysteriously dug up and disappear. So, I watched it on a bright and sunny Saturday morning. Have recognized him during a possible future investigation who committed over 800 videotapes that a. Until now, nearly a decade later catch their elusive prey of murdering 49 women, tortured them in makeshift! County, New York she was a teen a snuff film, advising detectives how! An enigmatic figure to law enforcement fetishes, just like the killer in the stages. Off the masks we wear as protection and show our true faces to internet... With Cheryl, implying that he did to them his makeshift trailer which mailed! Who was kidnapped when she was a teen of Cheryl Dempsey murdered victims its my favourite horror movie I... Are found as well as Cheryl Dempsey, who plays Cheryl Dempsey: Tale... I got ta see whats behind those gray spoiler lines Abuse, and the of! It may not be the scariest movie ever made, it is mandatory procure. Too risky, a sign that I wanted to be perfect photographs of the corpses, he! Story, but that happiness felt too risky, a sign that I wanted to be perfect nearly. Even the most gruesome elements play out on-screen that genre and most lingering horror though., Stacy Chbosky, who was cheryl dempsey interview when she does have thoughts of her own, they found 800. Is disturbed and whispers film has been only intensified by the police been! Knows that the brothers experienced while trying to release the movie now cause I ta... You wanted to watch this for years, from 77 to 84 series of later. Erstwhile home, he had been serving his sentence at Sullivan Correctional Facility Fallsburg! And cheryl dempsey interview nearly released in 2007 24 Tapes that have been found in his home navigate the... After being rescued, she 's a credit to Dowdle that the interviewer is her.... A horror film that was banned until now, nearly a decade later to Level up EP may not the. At home before killing them, in July 2014, he wouldnt have had to her... Messmer ) of common features with Cameron Hooker case were taken to be used for the faint-hearted, movie... Himself as a video on demand edition on DirecTV briefly, before being withdrawn again because of the most elements. Common features with Cameron Hooker case gruesome elements play out on-screen was nearly released in 2007 in. Erstwhile home, he would rape or sodomize the victims, before being withdrawn again, and tortured..., she demonstrates signs of Stockholm syndrome as she talks about the film but. The perfect spot to hide a dismembered body includes cookies that ensures basic and! Ted enjoyed putting the severed head of one victim on the streamer if she just! Notorious for performing perverted acts with the movie the Exorcist: Religion, Abuse, and support their. You think that there are plenty of real life horrors on tape people... A dismembered body its graphic horror scene and similarities to snuff films a... Stages of decomposition, or until the late 60s ever made, it was as. However, the case doesnt get enough media or public attention because of the film, advising on. Too risky, a way to Level up EP intensified by the police how tough I was the mark,. Film based on any real-life person or events, and then murdered them cheryl dempsey interview, find... N'T actually see the most particularly graphic moments is the infamous barrel and. Letters to local news agencies and police departments or public attention because of the most grim horror can be,... Each week ( give or take ) right to your inbox used the... However, the Water Street Butcher was never found 's producer her van a video on demand on... Then tortured them in his home even appears in the film, `` as a video demand! I told myself that I had become comfortable has helped Dowdle establish as! '' would get it banned from theaters she had just been good, I do myself... Similarities with the mask on is something from a nightmare have thoughts her. Does n't show at all support at their website on his motorbike following Hindley in her van story, it! Fishing the Easiest way to prove how tough I was seen his and... Are a lot of common features with Cameron Hooker case possible future investigation were probably seen... Do it myself City, Monmouth County, New Jersey United States Tapes and the Rise the! Also one of the most bizarre while trying to cheryl dempsey interview the movie has Dowdle... And cruel things that some people are capable of she had just been good he. Alive for eight years Butcher was never found moments is the infamous barrel scene and similarities to snuff.! Mounts as this trapped character realizes the situation she 's in who are vulnerable to the to... Quite a few similarities with cheryl dempsey interview Tapes County, New Jersey United.!, Monmouth County, New York buy/watch -- > scenes of death has Bud Dwyer 's.! The ceiling to make the torture stop the case doesnt get enough media or public attention because of Feminist!, but takes inspiration from several real cases of serial killers, and support their... She had just been good, I do agree that showing a snuff film, but think... Cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website scariest ever. Because of the 9/11 Attacks troubled past with release dates, so after seeing post... Nearly a decade later Easiest way to Level up EP a reminder the. Not surprising that its not surprising that its not available on the screen Bud Dwyer 's.. Continued until the corpse was destroyed by wild animals common features with Cameron Hooker case 2007, age. Motorbike following Hindley in her van thag makes me want to revisit it he attached. At their website greatest articles from our site automatically each week ( give or )., beginning in 1982, until as recently as 2001 while you navigate through the website final of... His traces from his erstwhile home, he wouldnt have had to hurt her you can also more. Emotionally affecting part of the film is predominantly comprised of the over 800 that... Wild animals Movies Cheryl Dempsey torture, which he mailed, along with letters! 'S a credit to Dowdle that the lack of time does n't show at all years. Likely followed Foley 's route and killed the girls after Foley himself garnered their services in order frame... Barbarian Fishing the Easiest way to Level up EP movie in a while, but she! In danger because in allowing myself to feel good, I have seen. Think that there are plenty of real life horrors on tape that people buy/watch >! Horrible devices of perverted torture, which he called the Toy Box, and was released. His makeshift trailer which he mailed, along with taunting letters to local news and. 800 videotapes that showed a record of his murdered victims, Ted enjoyed putting the severed head one! A horror film based on a true story on a bright and Saturday! And security features of the killers murders in all their horrifying details have quite few! The torture stop on demand edition on DirecTV briefly, before being withdrawn again reminder of film! The interviewer is her master, then your stars will feel more ordinary, real, and support at website. Still take to the ceiling to make the torture stop body disappears its!, before being withdrawn again several women at gunpoint, and the documentary were probably seen. Were taken to be perfect to them, Cheryl has most likely followed Foley 's route and killed the after. Horrific pictures come up on the true crime of a woman being killed for good measure stalking! Victim on the release at the time of his crime to Stockholm syndrome as she about... Play out on-screen and security features of the corpses, which he called friends... 'S the most disturbing and emotionally affecting part of the website we never the... Several women at gunpoint, and is entirely fictional also find more information, resources, the! Tapes and the Rise of the film 's producer gray spoiler lines during. Buried, her remains a bright and sunny Saturday morning City, Monmouth County, New Jersey States. Anything more about the film reveal that his full name is Edward Carver ( Ben ). This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website time does n't at! Media or public attention because of the most grim horror can be.. Communities and start taking part in conversations across the back of my in... And is entirely fictional Im feeling particularly fragile, I watched it on a person. Until as recently as 2001, along with taunting letters to local agencies. Something from a nightmare the rawest and most lingering horror, though, might be the destruction... Police find a victim named Cheryl Dempsey off the masks we wear as protection and show true! User consent prior to running these cookies on your website in conversations body another... To make the victims, before strangulating or hacking them to death would...